The Fatigue of Becoming Someone You Haven’t Met Yet

There’s a constant tug-of-war between who I am and who I need to become.

My natural instinct has always been to avoid the spotlight. Even as the top receiver on one of the most explosive offenses in NFL history, I never chased the lights. No interest in commercials. No craving for Pro Bowl votes. I was comfortable staying in the shadows of production—I didn’t care about visibility.

As a young player, I was a rising star in the NFL. In my first two years I was runner up for Rookie of the Year, and set an NFL record for most receptions in the first two seasons of a career. I was in prime position to become a marketing star.

But that was never what I wanted. I signed up to master my craft, not become an entertainer.

Choosing to stay in the shadows cost me opportunities—endorsements, campaigns, visibility plays. I even turned down big ones, like a Campbell’s Soup commercial with my mom, without hesitation.

People thought I was crazy for passing them up, but I never felt like I was missing out. I was confident and content with those decisions. I was not going to operate outside the integrity of who I was—for anyone.

The Entrepreneur’s Paradox

Now, as an entrepreneur, I live in a different paradox. The very instincts that served me on the field—the quiet focus, the discipline, the refusal to play for applause—can feel like friction when building a business.

Companies can’t scale in silence. Investors want a story. Partners want a face. Audiences want access. And yet, showing up in those ways often means stretching beyond the comfort of who you’ve always been.

There’s also another layer of complexity: navigating the perceptions of who people think you’re supposed to be based on your past.

To some, I’ll always be “the football player.” That lens shapes how they view me as an entrepreneur—what they expect, what they assume I can deliver, and even how they measure my credibility.

Acknowledging those perceptions exist in many of the new rooms I walk into forces me to balance not just my own growth, but the expectations others project onto me.

That’s the fatigue so many of us feel:

• The constant pressure to project a professional version of ourselves that lives outside our natural personality.

• The grind of becoming someone we haven’t fully met yet.

• The fear of evolving so far that we lose the thread of who we actually are.

Integrity vs. Evolution

Here’s the truth I’ve learned: the work isn’t to choose between authenticity and evolution. The work is to create capacity for both.

Integrity is the anchor—you never sacrifice it. But evolution requires intentional space.

You can’t grow into your next chapter by clinging to every instinct from the last one.

The fatigue sets in when you try to white-knuckle both. When you resist stretching because it feels inauthentic, but also resist being fully authentic because it feels inadequate for where you’re headed.

Playing the Long Game of Identity

The longer I’ve sat with this tension, the clearer it becomes: identity isn’t a static decision. It’s a long game.

Every chapter asks for a different version of you. The athlete version. The entrepreneur version. The investor, the parent, the partner. None of them cancel the others. But each requires space to grow—space you have to carve intentionally.

If you don’t, the world will define you by the version they met first. And that’s the surest way to get stuck.

What This Means for You

If you’re feeling the fatigue of becoming, here’s the lens I’d offer:

• Don’t confuse discomfort with inauthenticity. Growth always feels foreign at first.

• Protect your anchors. Know the values that don’t move, no matter the room.

• Design capacity. Build space—time, energy, margin—so you’re not forced to evolve on fumes.

• Play identity long. You’re not betraying yourself when you evolve—you’re compounding yourself.

The goal isn’t to hold your ground so tightly that you never move. The goal is to move far enough without losing the ground that matters most.

Closing Thoughts

The fatigue of becoming is real. I’ve lived it as an athlete who never chased the spotlight, and as an entrepreneur who can’t avoid it. And I’ve felt the weight of being measured by who people think I’m supposed to be, rather than who I’m still becoming.

The answer isn’t to pick one version of yourself and live there forever. The answer is to keep creating space for the next version—without letting go of the core that’s always been there.

Because when you learn to carry both integrity and evolution, you don’t just outlast perceptions of the past. You build a life that expands beyond them.

Ready to take the next step?

Whether you're pivoting careers, scaling your business, or redefining your next chapter, I help growth-minded professionals and organizations turn potential into sustainable success.

🚀 Learn more about my Thinking Partnership program →
Work with me 1:1 to uncover blind spots, build clarity, and create a personalized game plan that positions you for uncommon performance.

🛠️ Book me as a speaker or facilitator for your organization →
Looking to energize your team or leadership group? Book me for a custom session that delivers real results that move the needle.